Custom #2 pencils: how do you choose a pencil people keep and a logo people can read?
A promotional pencil is judged the first time someone sharpens it. Three things settle most of it: the lead and the wood, how readable your logo is on a narrow barrel, and the eraser.
Lead and wood come before price
In a non-scientific test of seven common pencil brands, a consumer website found, depending on the brand, lead that chipped during sharpening, wood that split and faint lines [1]. In a roundup of pencils tested by teachers (the test method isn't described), smooth writing and easy sharpening keep coming up as the qualities that matter [2].
The #2 label alone won't tell you how a pencil writes: it corresponds to the HB grade, but according to a specialty pencil retailer there is no universal standard, and the same grade varies from one brand to another [3]. A softer core writes darker but smudges more; a harder one writes lighter and holds its point [3]. For wood, a specialty blogger finds that cedar sharpens without splintering, an enthusiast's opinion [4]. Before a large order, sharpen and try a sample if you can.
A readable logo on a very narrow surface
An online printer recommends simplifying the logo, sticking to one short line of text, dropping fine details and relying on contrast: dark ink on a light barrel, light or metallic ink on a dark one [5]. So pick the barrel and imprint colours together.
The shape of the barrel also narrows your decoration options. At one American manufacturer, screen printing (up to three colours) is limited to round barrels and foil stamping comes with size and character limits on hexagonal ones, while multicolour digital printing and wraparound transfers remain available on them [6]; according to the same manufacturer, the hexagonal shape also offers a better grip and rolls less [7]. Offerings vary by supplier, so have the method confirmed before settling on a shape.
Keep the imprint away from the point, or sharpening will erase the text [6], without pushing it right up against the ferrule, the metal band that holds the eraser [5]. For an understated look on natural wood, laser engraving burns the mark into the wood, according to a distributor [8]; its comparative durability hasn't been established.
Eraser, sharpening and quantity
The consumer test also found erasers that smudged or crumbled [1], so test the eraser too. One manufacturer offers pencils without erasers and reports that some teachers prefer them because they can see how students work [7]. For schools, check scanner requirements [11] and coating lead limits [12].
A pre-sharpened pencil is ready to use right away, but its point is more likely to break in transit; opinions remain divided [9]. On budget, two sellers agree that the unit cost goes down as the quantity goes up [5][10]. Grouping a season's needs for the same pencil and the same imprint into one order can therefore lower the unit cost.
Écran Blanc's advice
For back-to-school, a trade show or a welcome kit, start with a pencil that sharpens cleanly and erases well, then fit the logo to the barrel rather than the other way around: one short line, strong contrast, well away from the point. Pre-sharpened pencils are handy on site; unsharpened ones travel better. Check readability on the proof.