Custom lapel pins: which process fits your logo and your purpose?
Before choosing a process, pin down what the pin is for, what your logo looks like and the garment it will be worn on.
Hard enamel, soft enamel or die-struck?
According to manufacturers, soft enamel leaves a texture you can feel with your fingertip, while hard enamel has a smooth, jewellery-like finish [1][2]. These two and a third manufacturer say hard enamel costs a little more [1][2][3], a gap one of them attributes to extra time and material [2]. Manufacturers credit it with a higher perceived value [2][3]; one associates it with employee recognition and membership pins, and points to soft enamel for trading, causes and branding instead [2]. Die-struck metal with no enamel keeps the natural look of the plating, a vintage finish popular for awards, according to one manufacturer [1].
Gradients or photos: where enamel stops
According to one manufacturer, enamel colours can't carry gradients or shading; manufacturers reserve printed pins for artwork with gradients, drop shadows or photos, and usually cover them with an epoxy dome to guard against scratches and wear [3][4]. The trade-off: a printed pin loses the raised metal lines, and one manufacturer gives it a lower perceived value [3]. Simplify the logo into flat colours and enamel becomes an option again.
A logo that still reads at pin size
According to one distributor, a line thinner than about 0.5 mm may disappear, and artwork that reads well at 50 mm can become illegible at 25 mm [5]. Prepare a pin version of your logo, without the tagline and with fewer colours, and judge it on a proof at actual size.
Brand colours: send the Pantone codes
According to one distributor, enamel is a physical pigment mixed from a recipe, so approving a shade on screen instead of by Pantone code can lead to a shade mismatch [6]. Include the codes from your brand guidelines with your price request; one manufacturer says it selects the closest Pantone equivalents and confirms them on the proof [7].
The pin back: a small detail that prevents losses
According to one manufacturer, a butterfly clutch can come loose by accident; jewellery-style or locking backs hold better, and a magnetic back secures the pin without piercing the fabric, which helps on thin material [8]. According to one distributor, replacing lost pins costs far more than a better back [6]. Say who will wear the pin and on what garment; for pins aimed at children, the Children's Jewellery Regulations may also apply [12].
Quantity: the mould changes the math
According to one manufacturer and one distributor, every enamel or die-struck design needs its own steel mould, a fixed cost regardless of quantity: that explains minimum quantities and a unit cost that drops as volume rises [9][6]. As long as the mould is kept on file, a reorder doesn't require a new one; how long it is kept varies by supplier (to be confirmed) [9][10]. For a tiered series, like a university that presents a pin for 5 to 25 years of service [11], estimate your needs over several years.
Écran Blanc's advice
Start from the message: for years of service or a membership, hard enamel or die-struck metal is worth considering first; for a tournament or a campaign, soft enamel may be enough. And review the proof the way you would a production drawing.